You are not buying a pump. You are buying a valve.
A 16 g CO2 cartridge is a sealed steel capsule holding carbon dioxide at a pressure far beyond anything your tire wants. The inflator is the thing in between: it pierces the cartridge, and then it decides how fast the gas leaves. That is the entire product.
Which means the useful question is not “how fast does it fill a tire” — they all fill a tire faster than you can get the levers back in the bag — but how much say do you get over the process. Can you put half the cartridge in, squeeze the tire, and add the rest? Or is it one squeeze and whatever happens, happens?
So this page ranks on what each listing publishes about control. Across these nine products, four publish a control mechanism— a gauge, a turn-screw, a trigger and a push-button. The other five publish nothing you could use to predict how the tool behaves in your hand.
The numbers this category does not publish
We read all nine live listings on 2 November 2026 and counted what was actually stated. The results are the reason this page exists.
One of nine publishes a pressure figure. One. On a category of products whose only job is to put a specific pressure into a tire. The Topeak publishes 160 psi because it has a gauge on it; everything else leaves you squeezing the tire with a thumb and guessing, which is exactly the technique our guide to road tire pressure spends two thousand words explaining is unreliable.
Two of nine publish a weight(16 g and 55 g — a 3.4x spread on an object you carry in a saddle bag for a year and use twice). Four of nine publish which valve they fit, which is remarkable given that half the bikes in an American garage are Schrader and half the road bikes are Presta. And three of nine say anything about whether gas is in the box— two say it is, one says plainly that it is not, and six leave you to find out.
The thing almost nobody mentions: it gets cold enough to hurt
When compressed CO2 expands it absorbs heat, and the metal it expands through gets extremely cold extremely fast. A brass or aluminum head attached to a discharging cartridge drops well below freezing in the second or two it takes to fill a tire. Bare skin held against cold metal sticks to it.
This is not a rumor and it is not a controversy; it is the same physics that makes an aerosol can cold in your hand, scaled up. The remedy is trivial — a neoprene sleeve over the cartridge, or a glove, or holding the head by its plastic rather than its metal.
Exactly one of the nine listings here mentions an insulated sleeve. Eight say nothing. We are not treating that as a product defect in eight cases, because a sleeve costs almost nothing and you can add one; we are treating it as the single most useful piece of information a first-time CO2 buyer is not being given, which is why it is in the second paragraph of this page rather than the eighteenth.
CO2 leaks out faster than air, and that is not a fault
Carbon dioxide passes through butyl rubber faster than the nitrogen and oxygen in air does. The practical consequence is well known to anyone who has used a cartridge: the tire you filled at the roadside on Saturday is noticeably soft by Sunday morning.
That is normal and it is not a sign the repair failed. It does mean a cartridge is a get-home tool rather than a top-up tool, and that the first thing you do when you get home is bleed the tire and refill it properly with a floor pump. If you are choosing between carrying CO2 and carrying a mini pump, our floor pump versus mini pump comparison makes the case for carrying both, and this is the reason.
If you run tubeless, read this before you buy any of them
Stan’s NoTubes — whose sealant is the reference product in the category — publishes a caveat that very few riders have seen: CO2 is best used in an emergency, and Stan’s recommends letting the CO2 out after the ride and replacing it with regular air, because prolonged exposure to CO2 can cause the sealant to separate and can degrade the liquid latex it depends on.
So if you are tubeless, a CO2 head is still the right thing to carry — it is the fastest way to re-seat a bead at the roadside — but it comes with a chore attached. Bleed and refill the same evening. Our guide to fixing a tubeless flat puts that in the repair ladder where it belongs, and the sealant roundup covers what you are protecting.
Threaded or unthreaded: get this right or the head is useless
CO2 cartridges come in two interfaces. Threaded cartridges have a screw thread around the neck; the head screws on, seals, and then pierces. Unthreaded cartridges are plain-necked and need a head that clamps and punctures.
Every head in this roundup that publishes an interface publishes a threadedone — Silca says “universal CO2 threaded cartridge compatible”, Lezyne says “Threaded CO2 Cartridge Compatible”, Blackburn says “Thread-On”, Ctrepower says “Screw-on Nozzle”. That is a quiet consensus and it is good news: threaded is the safer interface, because the seal is made before the seal is broken, and it is what almost every cartridge sold in the United States now uses.
Buy threaded cartridges unless you own an old head that demands otherwise. The sizes are 16 g, 20 g and 25 g: 16 g is the standard and is enough for one road tire; a 25 g is what you want for a wide gravel tire or a fat tire, because volume, not pressure, is what empties a cartridge.
Not a ranking. Six of the nine heads above publish nothing about whether a cartridge is included, so assume one is not. These are the consumables the job needs — threaded cartridges in the three common sizes, plus the levers and the tube that have to come out before the gas goes in.
The standard size, from the brand that supplies most American bike shops: a six-pack of threaded 16 g cartridges. One 16 g cartridge is roughly a road tire's worth of gas. Buy these if you ride 25 to 32 mm tires and want the cheapest per-fill option.
A five-pack of threaded 20 g cartridges, from a listing that also names 16 g and 25 g refill packs. Go up to 20 or 25 g if you ride wide gravel tires or fat tires, where a 16 g cartridge runs out before the tire is up.
Threaded cartridges published as fitting most threaded inflator heads, listed for road, MTB, gravel and hybrid. A second source for the same consumable — useful because cartridge stock is the thing that is out of stock when you need it.
You cannot inflate a tube you have not fitted. These are the levers the flat-repair guide uses; nylon so they do not score a rim, and wide enough to not fold on a tight tire bead.
The spare tube the cartridge is for. A CO2 head gets you home on a fresh tube in two minutes; a patch at the roadside takes twenty and needs the tire dry.
We haven’t tested any of these — they’re the parts the job above calls for, listed so you don’t have to go hunting. Prices are live from Amazon and we earn a commission if you buy. Prices as of November 16, 2026. #ad
How many cartridges should you carry?
Two, if you have room. One is a single point of failure in a tool category with no second chance — a cartridge that vents because the head went on crooked is gone, and so is your ride home. Riders who carry CO2 and nothing else have had this happen to them, which is the entire argument for also owning a mini pump.
If your saddle bag only takes one, carry one 25 g rather than one 16 g on anything wider than a road tire. And whatever you carry, check it twice a year: a cartridge that has been pierced even slightly bleeds down over months in a bag, and the first you will know about it is at the roadside. Our list of what to carry on a bike ride puts the cartridge, the head and the tube together as a single unit for exactly this reason.
What this page will not tell you
It will not tell you how many seconds any of these takes to fill a tire, because no listing publishes a figure and we have not timed one. It will not tell you how many psi a 16 g cartridge puts into a 700x28 tire, because that depends on the tire volume, the rim, the temperature and how much gas you lose seating the head — and any single number we printed would be wrong for most readers.
It will not rank these on build quality, because “CNC Aluminum Construction” and “Aluminum Alloy Construction” are the only two material claims published across nine products and neither comes with a grade. And it will not tell you which one feels best in the hand, because feeling things in the hand is testing, and we do not do that here.
What it tells you is what nine sellers chose to state about their own products, counted and compared. On that test the ranking is not close: one listing publishes a pressure, a weight and a gauge, and eight do not.